« Renaming Files As They Are Uploaded (how CFFILE actually works) | Main | Flex 1.0 Updater 2 Is Live »

July 14, 2004

Macromedia Forums

Just wondering how many of you out there use the Macromedia web-based forums on a regular basis. Any specific feedback you'd like to pass along?

How many of you are using NNTP rather than the web-based forums? Anything in particular about the NNTP hook you'd like to report?

And finally, what news readers do you like for both Windows and Mac? I've tried several for OS X, and I can't find one I like. Rather than reading dozens of news reader reviews before trying another batch, I'd rather get some feedback from my readers since it's obvious you have excellent taste!

Posted by cantrell at July 14, 2004 05:39 PM | References

Comments

I use the web-based only.

Posted by: Joel at July 14, 2004 05:52 PM

The NNTP format is better since it's faster and easier (maybe not for beginners) since we have the discussions nicely grouped and can benefit from the news-reader's options and features that are IMHO better than what we find in the web-based forum.

I use Outlook Express but I'm seriously evaluating Thunderbird from Mozilla.

Posted by: Alex Hubner at July 14, 2004 06:26 PM

BTW: the general brazilian forum at "forums.macromedia.com" is a good example of the preference for NNTP system. I believe it also improves the number of participants and messages.

Posted by: Alex Hubner at July 14, 2004 06:27 PM

Whilst at work I use the web forums, mainly cause the Systems guys have blocked the damn NNTP port in the firewall. Due to this I end up using the web forums at home too .. simply because I'm used to them.

Posted by: Andy Allan at July 14, 2004 06:33 PM

I use both but prefer nntp simply because it's quicker and easier to keep track of threads you are involved or interested in.

Posted by: Peter Witham at July 14, 2004 07:17 PM

I usually use Google Groups for searches because the Macromedia Web Forums are so damn slow.

Posted by: Michael Brennan-White at July 14, 2004 07:33 PM

I use the web interface... Don't know why. :)

Posted by: Nathan Strutz at July 14, 2004 07:42 PM

Christian: I use RSS. I'm subscribed to the various feeds, and then I have Newzcrawler set to watch them for mentions of things I can actually help with... XML, RSS, blogging, etc.

Posted by: Roger Benningfield at July 15, 2004 03:17 AM

I tend to use the web-based interface, but it's been so flakey lately that I've started using NNTP. I'm on Mac OS X and have just been using Microsoft Entourage 2004 as my news reader--I'm not overwhelmingly impressed with it but it's fairly nice and keeps me from having to use the browser for my Hotmail account as well. I haven't tried Thunderbird yet but plan to.

Posted by: Matt Woodward at July 15, 2004 08:33 AM

I use NNTP only because it's faster and it's easier to archive posts of interest. It's also easier to follow threads and see who is replying to what message.

Using the Web based forums is so slow and awkward it's like trying to run in 4 feet of water... painful ;-)

I use Mozilla mail at work and Thunderbird at home to read the newsgroups.

Posted by: Stéphane Bergeron at July 15, 2004 11:09 AM

I tend to use the Forums for MM since I'm used to it and never remember the NNTP. For other newsgroups I use Xnews (free). I find its comprehensive and fast and pretty stable with a low memory consumption.

The 'test' version, 6.07.17 seems stable to me. http://xnews.newsguy.com/

Posted by: Ryan at July 15, 2004 12:13 PM

I use NNTP to access the forums, but wouldn't this be perfect for a Flex application?

Posted by: Nisse Bryngfors at July 15, 2004 05:27 PM

I use both interfaces (surprised?), but use NNTP more for historical archiving and the webforums for most day-to-day postings (the email notification of new posts in threads I've created helps a lot to follow up on discussions I've jumped into).

Regarding NNTP newsreaders- on Mac it's Thunderbird all the way for me. Used to use Entourage but found it very very flakey and crash-prone, IMHO. I've gravitated towards Gravity on the PC for NNTP (my primary newsreader). Weird interface at first, but a great application once I got used to it.

Just my $.02, from an admittedly biased point of view... ;-)

Posted by: Scott Fegette at July 15, 2004 06:25 PM

NNTP via Outlook Express.

Posted by: since1968 at July 15, 2004 11:19 PM

Its gotta be NNTP via Thunderbird (i would use OE as i prefer it but the bugs just get me too paranoid). Personally i really do preferer NNTP over web based forums as the are 100% slower, less is to quick scan, harder to keep track of posts. I think becuase you use an app for NNTP that you have a host of extra options for reading and trackin which make life easier.

Posted by: Andy Jarrett at July 16, 2004 05:04 AM

Just thought I'd share that XNews is an excellent freeware newsreader, though I've yet to test out T-bird

Posted by: Brent Morris at July 16, 2004 09:35 AM

i use the web forums as i always have a browser open somewhere - i use Firefox - i like the web forums because i like the option of editing my posts (i'm a terrible typist) and other options the web forums allow. What i dont like is the delay when clicking reply and the delay when sending/posting - sometimes i wait up to 20 seconds - i'm on broadband and on Win XP and 2000 Pro.

Posted by: chris at July 20, 2004 10:18 PM